Table 2. Resident Performance During the Final Skills Assessment
VariableTransverse ApproachOblique ApproachLongitudinal ApproachP Value
Residents' preferred approach to central venous access, % (95% CI)0.01
 First choice87.5a (78.4-93.6)12.5b (6.4-21.6)0.0b (0.0-3.4)
 Second choice9.7a (4.5-18.1)44.4b (33.4-56.0)45.8b (34.7-57.3)
 Third choice2.8a (0.6-8.6)43.1b (32.1-54.6)54.2b (42.7-65.3)
Failure of technique, % (95% CI)1.4a (0.2-6.3)9.7b (4.5-18.1)2.8ab (0.6-8.6)0.02
Successful cannulation on first attempt, % (95% CI)78.9 (68.3-87.1)76.9 (65.7-85.9)82.9 (72.8-90.3)ns
Carotid artery puncture, % (95% CI)0.0 (0.0-3.5)1.5 (0.2-7.0)7.1 (2.8-14.9)ns
Skin-to-vein time, seconds, mean (95% CI)17.6 (12.1-23.2)19.2 (13.4-25.0)18.4 (12.3-24.4)ns
  • a,b For each variable, means or proportions in a line with the same or no superscript do not differ (P>0.05). Statistical significance is defined as P ≤ 0.05.

  • CI, confidence interval; ns, nonsignificant.